Building Teams That Thrive, Not Just Survive

By Charis Musick

I recently rewatched a 2002 classic—Drumline, one of my personal childhood favorite movies. Sometimes I just need an old, familiar film that brings me joy, and the artistry and skill of southern drumline competitions was just what I was looking for.

What I was not looking for—or expecting—was the reiteration of a leadership lesson we often talk about with our clients.

Follow me...

Ironically, that was the first lead-in—no pun intended—to my thoughts about a particular leadership lesson.

In the movie, Dr. Lee is the musically gifted marching band director at Atlanta A&T. Devon Miles is the highly skilled drummer Dr. Lee recruited out of high school. Devon arrives on campus with undeniable talent. His technical ability is extraordinary. His confidence is even bigger. Before long, he earns a coveted position as a freshman drummer in the drumline's top rank—a place typically reserved for upperclassmen.

He's the best drummer in the room.

And that's exactly the problem.

Throughout the movie, Devon repeatedly demonstrates what happens when skill outpaces maturity. He challenges authority. He disregards team standards. He elevates individual performance over collective success. He wants the recognition that comes with leadership without embracing the responsibility that leadership requires.

At one point, Dr. Lee tells him, "Before you can lead, you have to learn to follow."

That's not just a lesson for drumlines. It's a lesson for every team.

One of the most common mistakes leaders make when building teams is assuming that talent alone is enough. We often become enamored with competence. We promote the highest performer. We make exceptions for the most gifted employee. We overlook character concerns because the results are impressive.

But thriving teams are not built on talent alone. 

They're built on trust.

They're built on accountability.

They're built on people who understand that individual excellence must serve collective success.

Devon's greatest challenge wasn't learning how to play better. He already knew how to do that. His greatest challenge was learning how to become part of something bigger than himself.

The reality is that every organization has a "Devon."

The salesperson who consistently exceeds quota but leaves relational damage in their wake.

The leader who gets results but undermines culture.

The employee who is incredibly talented but believes the rules apply to everyone else.

The challenge for leaders is deciding what matters most. Do we prioritize performance at all costs? Or do we build cultures where performance and character are expected to coexist?

What's fascinating is that Dr. Lee himself learns a leadership lesson throughout the film.

His rival, Morris Brown band director Mr. Wade, represents a very different philosophy. Dr. Lee is committed to musical precision and artistic excellence. Mr. Wade is committed to energy, entertainment, and moving the crowd.

Neither leader is entirely right.

Nor entirely wrong.

While Mr. Wade demonstrates significant integrity flaws throughout the story, there is still something Dr. Lee can learn from him. Excellence without engagement can become disconnected. Tradition without adaptation can become stagnant.

What ultimately elevates Atlanta A&T is not abandoning artistry for entertainment or entertainment for artistry. It's finding a way to marry both.

Dr. Lee begins leaning into the strengths of younger leaders like Devon Miles and Sean Taylor. The old school and the new school find a way to work together. Tradition and innovation stop competing and start collaborating. In many ways, that's another picture of healthy leadership.

Thriving organizations know how to bridge generations.

They honor what got them here while remaining open to what could take them further.

They preserve core values while adapting methods.

They create space for wisdom and fresh perspective to coexist.

But none of that happens without leadership maturity.

One of my favorite moments in the movie is when Dr. Lee reminds Sean Taylor of his own leadership journey. Sean is wrestling with the pressure of leading peers who once stood beside him. Dr. Lee reminds him of where he started and encourages him to step into the leader he has become.

Great leaders do that.

They don't just correct performance. They develop people.

They remind others of their potential when fear, insecurity, or self-doubt begin to cloud their vision.

Which brings me back to Devon.

Despite all his talent, he ultimately faces consequences for misrepresenting himself on his application. The issue wasn't his ability. It was his integrity. And that's the lesson I couldn't stop thinking about.

When building teams that thrive—not just survive—it isn't enough to recruit the most talented people in the room.

Talent matters.

Competence matters.

Results matter.

But culture matters too.

Character matters.

Integrity matters.

The healthiest organizations refuse to separate performance from values. They don't lower standards for high performers. They don't excuse unhealthy behavior because someone is gifted. They understand that what you tolerate today becomes the culture you inherit tomorrow.

A thriving team is not simply a collection of talented individuals.

It's a community of people aligned around a shared purpose, committed to shared standards, and willing to place collective success above personal recognition.

That's what Devon had to learn.

And if we're honest, it's a lesson every leader eventually has to learn too.

Because the goal isn't to build a team full of stars.

The goal is to build a team capable of performing together.